Hi! It’s that time again! This month’s Recipe ReDux challenge, small bites to celebrate big events, has got to one of my favorites! Everyone lo
ves bite sized treats. They are just so darn cute!
And this is not just any challenge. Recipe ReDux celebrates their 1 year anniversary! I have been happy to be part of ReDux from day one. It has gotten me to challenge myself, have more fun in the kitchen, and meet fabulous bloggers (and cooks) along the way!
My recipe this month is inspired by one of my favorite childhood summer treats, the ice cream sandwich. We had an ice cream truck drive down our cul de sac once in a blue moon. When it did, an ice cream sandwich topped my list of favorite sweet treats. This is the perfect dessert to make into popable (it’s a word, right?) bites as any ice cream sandwich eaters know; it can get a bit messy.
This recipe is also a tad bit healthier. I substituted white flour for whole wheat pastry flour along with using natural peanut butter for the cookies. Although the texture was slightly different, the taste was still there! Peanut butter perfection!
Mini Peanut Butter Ice Cream Sandwiches (makes over 20 minis)
For peanut butter cookies:
Ingredients:
- 1/2 cup unsalted butter
- 1/2 cup natural peanut butter
- 1/2 cup white sugar
- 1/2 cup packed brown sugar
- 1 egg
- 1 1/4 cups whole wheat pastry flour
- 1/2 teaspoon baking powder
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 3/4 teaspoons baking soda
For assembly of sandwiches:
- Slow churned vanilla ice cream (or favorite ice cream)
- Chocolate pieces, chopped thin
Directions:
Cream together butter, peanut butter and sugars.
Beat in egg.
In a separate bowl, sift together flour, baking powder, baking soda, and salt.
Stir into batter.
Put batter in refrigerator for 1 hour.
To make minis, use about a teaspoon of dough and roll into ball. Flatten each ball with a fork, making a criss-cross pattern. .
Bake in a preheated 375 degrees F oven for about 7-8 minutes or until cookies begin to brown. Do not over-bake
Ta da!!
They are too cute!
Once the cookies are baked, you are ready to assemble the sandwiches!
Start by chopping up chocolate pieces. You could also try rolling the sandwiches using mini chips too.
Get your ice cream of choice ready to scoop.
I totally forgot to take a picture of the assembly, but scoop the ice cream between two cookies and roll into chocolate.
The final result!!
I made these minis for Father’s Day (hence the pb cookie..dads fav!) and they were a hit! I loved that they were so simple to eat.
I still can’t get over the size!! Doesn’t it just make you want to smile.
The perfect treat for those hot summer days. ENJOY!
To check out past ReDux challenges, visit my link here.
Other Swanky Scoop:
Be sure to enter my slow cooker giveaway if you haven’t yet!
Thanks for reading!
What was your favorite childhood treat growing up?









{ 42 comments… read them below or add one }
Those look so good! Great pics too! My favorite dessert as a kid was ice cream in general – I had a huge bowl every single night before bed until I went to college and had no freezer
These are adorable! Can food be adorable?!!? I love everything mini sized!
Yum! I would eat a few dozen of those
My daughter is thanking you for these recipe. Perfect little bite of deliciousness!
Thanks Danielle!! Yes, they are perfect for the kids!
all i want to know is why have i never made ice cream sandwiches??? these look amazing!
Thanks Elizabeth!
It’s funny cause I hardly ever made them growing up. Don’t know why not!!
So cute! I love ice cream cookie sandwiches too. This is definitely the perfect way to enjoy them without making a big, melty, ice cream mess!
Definitely need to try this! What a fun summer treat to make with my 3 year old.
Oh my goodness. This just looks perfect! I don’t know if I could ever stop eating these!
Cute!
those are adorable!!! perfect for summer! can i count those as a cookie friday?! i should make them tomorrow. I don’t have it planned yet!!!
My goodness – these look amazing! So cute and they sound incredibly delicious. Plus, I’m a fan of anything bite sized
Mmm…these combine three of the world’s best sweet treats (peanut butter, ice cream and chocolate)! Yum. I may give them a whirl for a party I’m hosting next week; what’s more fun than bite-sized ice cream sandwiches?!
Oh great!!! Yes, they are too cute!
I love your popable treats! I was looking for some small ice cream snacks at the grocery store the other day, but couldn’t find any…These cuties are absolutely perfect for popping!
I agree! It is hard to find mini ice cream desserts.
Absolutely adorable and yummy looking!:-)
I love peanut butter cookies, and I think I’d love them even more in your ice cream sandwich form!
I completely agree!!
Thanks for stopping by, Jennifer!
I don’t think I could stop at one! These looks so cute- and kid friendly!!
Yeah, that’s probably where you can get in trouble.
Although they are mini, they are too good!
THE ICE CREAM MAN CAME THROUH MY NEIGHBORHOOD LAST WEEK! I got so excited (I didn’t get anything) but just the noise of the cracking music and squeaky truck flooded me with memories of childhood. I used to get the fruity ice creams, then I grew up and started getting the toll house cookies just like this!!
I have been doing something similar lately, but a bit more lazy. Instead of making my own cookies I have been buying the vegan choc chip cookies from TJ’s and some dairy free ice cream. Then making my sandwich and poppin it in the freezer for about 10min. This is my after spin or after a run treat. I love your mini ones!
YUM!
I think it is nice too because you don’t have to feel guilty with just a couple minis.
YUM! Those look so so delicious!
Weeee!!! I love how tiny these are! I have butter pecan icecream in my freezer too – don’t you think that would go well with peanut butter cookies?
Have a fab weekend!
Definitely!!! I think that would be perfect! I am craving these now as I type this comment.
Hi! My name is Ashley and I’m interning with the Meal Makeover Moms. Thanks for this fun recipe- ice cream sandwiches were definitely a summer favorite of mine as well! With a couple ingredient substitutions and proper portioning, it can easily become a part of a healthy diet.
Hi Ashley!
Thanks for stopping by! I hope you enjoy your internship..what a fun rotation!
Such a cute post! I love the flashback to your favorite childhood treat! I love going out for ice cream as a kid…it was few and far between. Baskin Robins is where we went…that is my memory. You can never go wrong with ice cream…or peanutbutter! In my book the PERFECT combination!!!
This is a recipe after my own heart. I love the idea of ice cream sandwiches, but they are definitely over the top in terms of the portion. I love your recipe. Really cute and such a reasonable portion!
Thanks Liz!
This was such a fun idea for a challenge!
Icecream sandwiches. Way to take my breath away. I love them. They are a huge weakness of mine. I just bought banana split so delicious ice cream sandwiches. Obviously yours look waaaaay better. I’m going to have to make these for my friends and I since it is so stinking hot in Texas right now!
also I forgot to mention that I love this idea that dietitians have something like this out there. I love that I have chosen to go into this field!
What a cute & delicious treat! I didn’t really like sweet things growing up (I know, I was a weird kid). In my 30s I discovered dark chocolate. It’s my treat of choice these days…
I seriously need to make a dairy free version of these, complete with homemade vanilla (coconut milk) ice cream. If they’re mini, does that mean you can eat more?
Haha, yes!
I love the idea of homemade ice cream using coconut milk. YUM!
Ooh! This Recipe Redux Challenge sounds really fun! Thank you for sharing! I’m def interested in joining =). The mini ice cream sandwiches are soo cute!! And what do you know? I have all those ingredients on hand. Well..except for the slow-churned ice cream. I have a gallon of full-fat Cookies ‘n Cream in my freezer. I’m sure it will work just fine too, don’t you think? =)
Thanks so much, Min!
Here is the link for Recipe ReDux. http://professionalpalate.squarespace.com/thereciperedux
These look so cute and delicious! I agree with your dad, peanut butter cookies are my favorite too! Thanks so much for sharing your recipe!
Molly Jones
Intern for ReganMillerJones, Inc.
Thanks Molly!!
So glad you stopped by!
mouth is watering.